The Africans of India

The Indian society is a beautiful piece of fabric with many colours. As I explained in some of my previous articles, the various clans we see among the Indian castes today are also a result of migration, both in and out of India during the last 2,000 years.


Marfa band of the Siddis. Picture credit THE HINDU.

Among these different castes or clans, there is one known as the Siddi people. They are not natives of India, they are actually descendants of the Bantu people from Africa. The Siddis were brought to India few hundred years ago. They are mostly Muslims. Many served in the army of the Mughals.

Some of you, especially those within my circle of friends would have remembered a discussion which we had few months ago. It was regarding the Siddis and also the tribes of Andaman.

On 9 February 2014, a professor from Sweden contacted me via my Facebook page. He noticed my writings and requested me to spread some of his research. It was an honor to be acknowledged by this professor.

I will post his research works in this article today. It will be below this image. Enjoy reading!




LINGUISTIC EVIDENCE OF BANTU ORIGINS OF THE SIDIS OF INDIA by Prof. Abdulaziz Lodhi, Uppsala University (Sweden).

[Published in TADIA: The African Diaspora in Asia – Explorations on a less known fact. Banglore, India, 2008. p. 301-313. Gujarati translation of the paper as a separate booklet “Gujarat-na Sidi lok-no Itihas” (= A history of the Sidi people of Gujarat) published by Sidi Goma & Al-Mubrik Charitable Trust, Bhavnagar, India, 2008.]

Abstract
The Sidis of India are fragmented communities of mostly East African ancestry. They are descendants of Muslim African traders, sailors, mercenaries and slaves. They speak half a dozen different Indic languages (Gujarati dialects, or a mixture of Gujarati and Hindi, Sindhi and its dialect Cutchi, Urdu, Dakhini, Marathi, Malayalam, Konkani and Kannada, with some Bantu/Swahili words and phrases.

Free Eastern Africans were recruited, or African slaves were randomly caught, from different tribal lands; they usually spoke related languages and several individuals in any one free contingent or slave shipment came from the same area or were members of the same language group. Hence they could communicate in an African language in the beginning; but as mixed groups, small in number and spread over wide areas surrounded by large Indian languages with a long literary tradition, they could not maintain nor transmit their original languages and cultures to posterity. Instead they became localised, retaining only few East-central 

African elements in their speech. Islam, the religion of the politically dominant section of the Indian society of the last millenium with whom most of the Sidis were initially allied, became a common denominator of their cultural identification and also facilitated their social and linguistic integration, and economic, political and military success in many areas, before the advent of European colonial rule.

The available Bantu linguistic data in the speech of the Sidis, erroneously identified by several writers as Swahili, appears to have been derived from languages spoken in Mainland Tanzania. In recent years, research interest in the various Sidi and Shidi communities has given them a wider recognition. Sidi cultural societies have been participating internationally with their Muslim Sufi song and dance and their renewed contacts with East Africa have increased slightly the number of Bantu words in their language use, such as Swahili greetings, emphasising their East African heritage and misconceiving Swahili as their ancestral language.


1. Introduction
Scattered and less known communities of African descent in the Indian sub-continent, Sri Lanka and the nearby islands in the Indian Ocean are generally known as Sidi or Siddi. Their presence in India was first mentioned in colonial annals as a novelty or in Census Reports (Freeman.Grenville 1988:XVII). However, recently several serious studies about their history, social organisation, cultural and economic activity, their military exploits in the various colonial armies and their political participation have been presented at international conferences by both Indian and Western scholars (Indian Ocean Studies Conference 2002, UCLA, Jayasuriya and Pankhurst 2003). 

2. Historical background
Camara (1997) reported the self-identifying “Afro-Indians”, i.e. Indians of African origin in India, to number about 35 000, settled in Gujarat, Maharashtra, Andhra Pradesh, Kerala and Karnataka, and in the former Portuguese territories of Daman, Diu and Goa. Today their number is estimated to be 76 000 in Gujarat alone. In Gujarat they are found in the districts of Ahmedabad, Amerili, Jamnagar, Junagadh, Rajkot, Bhavnagar, Bharuch, Ratanpur, Surendranagar and Cutch. According to the Census Report of India (Naik & Pandya, 1981), Sidis in Gujarat in 1971 numbered about 5000 and during the past decades their number has increased slightly and has been fairly constant there because of migration, mainly to the Mumbai region. They are normally settled in areas/hamlets/villages of their own but in Ahmedabad, Bharuch and Cutch they live in mixed areas as they do in parts of Andhra Pradesh.

These Afro-Indians are variously known as Sidhi/Sidi/Siddi or Habshi/Habsi in India, Shidi/Shidee in Pakistan and Kaffir in Sri Lanka. It is generally accepted by scholars that these ethnonyms tell us that the Sidis were in the employ of Sayyads, the Muslim rulers of India, and that many of them came from Ethiopia and Sudan in the 1500s as mercenaries and prisoners of war sold as slaves (Pankhurst 2003). The Arabic religious and/or aristocratic title ‘Sayyad’ or ‘Sayyid’is usually given as the etymology of the ethnonyms Sidhi, Sidhdhi, Siddi, Sidi, or Shidi. 

My recent research into the etymology of the term Sidi, and its variants, suggests a possible alternative meaning of the term Sidi, i.e. Arabic ‘saydi’ with the emphatic /ŝ/ consonant ‘saad’ (ﺺ ) meaning "captive" or "prisoner of war" instead of the established Arabic religious and/or aristocratic title ‘Sayyad’, ‘Sayyid’, ‘Seyyid’, Sayed or ‘Syed’ with the non-emphatic /s/ consonant ‘siin’ (ﺲ) which is ultimately reduced to ‘Sidi’ in many African dialects of Arabic, whereas the former term with the emphatic / ŝ / consonant is not reduced in this way.

In the past, Sudanese and Ethiopian prisoners of war were sold as slaves to other African rulers who sold them to slave traders who in turn brought them to the Middle East and India. As late as the beginning of the 20th century, in the Ottoman armies there were more than 10 000 African mercenaries spread all over the Ottoman empire. The term Sidi might have been borrowed in India from early Arabic/Ottoman usage. In pre-Ottoman period, African soldiers in India were referred to as Habshi or Habsi). Early African soldiers in India appear to have been mostly freemen and mercenaries, and it has been established that there were several groups of Africans who were traders and sailors who had immigrated to India. Thus all Africans in India were not slaves nor were they of slave descent. However, Sidis in the Portuguese enclaves and most Sidi females in domestic employ in the aristocratic households were probably slaves or of slave origin. Ian Hancock (PC 1996) is of the opinion that many Sidis appear to have deserted the various armies at different times and found refuge among the Gypsy/Roma already in India and also after the Roma came to Europe, and got assimilated. This is sometimes apparent in the physiognomy of some Roma with darker complexion and somewhat wooley hair. 

A great majority of the Sidis of India today are Sunni Muslims, and the few Hindus and Christians are found in Daman, Goa and Karnataka. The Karnataka Sidis are descendants of the deserters who left Portuguese Goa and fled to the forest across the border, and they most probably originate in Mozambique and Angola. 

The Sidis are loosely organised into mostly endogamous tribes or professional castes. The Royal Sidis are survivors of the former Sidi State of Jafarabad established by the Sidi Naval Chief of Janjira during the time of the warrior King Shivaji of the Maratha in the mid-1600s. These Jafarabad Sidis together with the Royal Sidis in Hyderabad, Aurangabad and the former Sidi principalities of Radhanpur in the Kathiawar region of north Gujarat, and in Sachin near the port of Surat, marry mostly among themselves or with upper class/caste Muslim Indians. In some cases they have special tribal names such as the Tai of Saurashtra, the Shemali of Jambur (probably of Somali origin) , the Kafara of Diu (probably from southern Mozambique and/or South Africa) and the Saheli of Daman (probably from the Kenya-Tanzania coast). In a few cases in Cutch they also have traditional Indian caste names such as Sidhi Langa (Musicians/Drummers), Sidhi Dhobi (Washermen) and Sidhi Kharwa (Sailors).

The Kafara Sidi of Diu have maintained some of their East African customs and a few linguistic items. Small groups of Shemali Sidis and Saheli Sidis have kept alive some rites and rituals from their East African Bantu past, but otherwise the Sidis are de facto Indians since they speak Indian languages as their mother-tongues and practice mostly the Indian variant of Sunni Islam with the Indian Sufi cult of pir (saint) with rituals and celebrations performed at a dargah (mausoleums, shrine). At these shrines they worship also ancestors and founders of settlements (Patel 1986, Catlin 2002, Basu 2002, and Shroff 2002). 

There are several legends about the origins of some early Sidi settlements but so far no contemporary written record has been found to verify their early oral history or substantiate the Sidi claims of various ancestries; however, there are a few early reports by European officials and travellers and one short language study by the explorer Richard F. Burton (1851). 

According to one commonly accepted legend (Patel 1986), the founder of the Sidi settlement in Jambur in Gujarat is supposed to have originally come from Kano in Nigeria via the Sudan and Mecca after his Hajj pilgrimage. This leader was a wealthy merchant by the name of Bawa/Baba Ghor who first settled in the Rajpipla Hills near Bharuch and Khambat where he developed mining and trade in agate, the precious stone known as akik in India. A certain variety of agate beads are known as Baba Ghori; another maroon cornelian stone is named after his sister and successor Mai Mariyam, also known as Mai Misra/Mishra. 

It appears that a large number of Sidis came, or were brought, to India from different parts of Africa as soldiers to serve in the Muslim armies of the Nawabs and Sultans - hence their Muslim faith and relative absence of the Hindu caste system among them. Many were officials in the Muslim, and later Hindu, armies and as royal bodyguards some of them rose to power in more than one place i.e. Jafarabad, Radhanpur, Ahmedabad and Aurangabad. Some were singers and ceremonial drummers. In Gujarat the drummers are known as nagarchi, and the Chief Drummer had the title of nagarsha(h) (King of Drums). In Cutch and Sindh, the Sidi singer-drummers are known as langa (male lango, female langi) and they are prestigious and respectable professionals. It is also claimed by the Shemali Sidi that one of Bawa Ghor's younger brothers was a nagarsha in the former Kingdom of Madhapur, and he is worshipped as one of the several pirs in Jambur.

Some Sidis came to India as special servants in the courts of Muslim Nawabs and Sultans, some came as herbalists and midwives, a few were brought by Indian merchants returning home from Africa, and a few were brought as domestic slaves especially in the Portuguese territories (Shirodkar 1985:27 and passim).

Noble north Indian families had a convention of keeping Habshi, or other non-Indians, as personal attendants since servants having no local social or blood connections or roots guaranteed political loyalty and security (as was the case with the Arab/Omani sultans of Zanzibar whose armed forces and administrative personnel consisted mainly of the Balochi and Makrani of Iran/Pakistan, and Cutchi/Sindhi and Pathan of north-west India). Very few African slaves were brought to the Indian sub-continent to provide cheap labour. 

Ownership of African slaves was an expensive affair since local Indian feudal practices related to slavery provided abundant indigenous cheap or free labour to rulers, land-owners and the upper castes. The rulers of India could also obtain slaves of various categories from other parts of Asia, Eastern Europe and the Caucasus. The descendants of these slaves of different origins in most Muslim societies generally cannot be distinguished as racial or ethnic groups or minorities since most of them were employed in the higher administration and the armies, serving different governments and later marrying the natives. As Bates & Rassam (1989) describe it, they were a kind of life-long servants of the ruler, rather than slaves in the Western sense.

3. The Sidis today
Before the coming of the British rule in India, the Sidis were undergoing a process of assimilation, but the British divide-and-rule policy segregated the Sidi groups from one another and also from the indigenous Indian communities in which they lived. As a result, the Sidis have been ‘re-tribalised’ and have become impoverished in many areas. 

Those Sidi settlements in Gujarat which are organised as separate communities with a tribal system existing outside the main political stream and currents of socio-economic development, have been classified by the Central Government as Scheduled Tribes and they get Central Government support. Jambur Village near Madhapur with its own panchayat (Five Member Leadership Committee), a primary school and a shop, was the first Sidi enclosure to get such support (Census of India 1961). Most Sidis in Gujarat are farmers and unskilled workers, but in other regions one finds Sidi doctors, lawyers, policemen, journalists, technicians, teachers, businessmen and land-owners. There is an inter-state movement to organise and unite all the Sidi groups and improve their economic conditions and raise their social status. An increasing number of them are realising economic improvement as entertainers in the growing tourist industry. 

3.1 The Language situation of the Sidis
East Africans slaves were randomly caught, or were recruited from different tribal lands; they usually spoke related languages and several individuals came from the same area or were members of the same ethnic group. For these reasons they could communicate in an Eastern African language in the beginning, but as mixed groups, small in numbers and spread over wide areas surrounded by large Indian languages with a long tradition, they could not maintain nor transmit their original languages and cultures to future generations. Instead they became indianised, leaving few African linguistic traces in their speech and cultural registers of terminology. Another factor was Islam, the religion of the politically dominant section of the Indian society with whom the Sidis were initially allied, which became a common denominator of their cultural identification and also facilitated their social and linguistic integration, and economic, political and military success in many areas before the advent of the British colonial rule.

Thus the Sidis today speak Gujarati (or a mixture of Gujarati and Hindi) in the Saurashtra region of Gujarat; in the district of Cutch they speak Cutchi (a dialect of Sindhi), and in Daman and Diu they speak the local Gujarati dialects with a few Swahili/Bantu words and phrases. In Sindh they speak Sindhi and also Urdu, and Dakhini in Andhra Pradesh. Other groups of Sidis speak Marathi, Malayalam, Konkani or Kannada according to their region of settlement. 

Richard Burton’s wordlist of 1851 is “a brief and random lexicon (Freeman-Grenville 1988:18)” of the Sidi language as spoken in coastal Sindh and Cutch at that time and contains altogether 122 words and phrases, numerals and 22 place names including some tribal homelands; the latter are all derived from languages spoken in Tanzania (Shambaa, Zigua, Ngindo and Yao) which points to the Tanzanian mainland as their original home. In other parts of the Indian sub-continent, some linguistic items from Mozambique (from Makua, Nyanja and Yao languages) and Malawi (Nyanja/Chewa) have been identified. 

The following is a short list extracted from Richard Burtons “Sidi” language (collected in Sindh during 1849-50, and not claimed by him nor by the contemporary Sidis to be Swahili).

Burton’s ‘Sidi language’ Modern/Standard Swahili (based on Zanzibar Town)
moto moto (fire; hot)
komongo chuma (iron, iron bar)
maji maji (water)
nyumba nyumba (house, home)
somba samaki, insi, nswi (fish)
vura mvua (rain)
khundoro kondoo/khondoo (sheep)
mawingo mawingu (clouds)
pinde pinde (bow)
mukoki mkuki (spear)
menu meno (teeth)
nyoere nywele (hair)
muguru mguu (foot)
macho macho (eyes)
devo ndevu, devu (beard)
mototo mtoto (child, son)
baba ya baba (father)
viyakazi (daughter) vijakazi (slave girls, maids)
moya moja (one)
perhi mbili (two), pili (second)
tahtu tatu/thathu (three)
mme nne (four)
thano tano/thano (five)
thandatu sita (six)
fungate saba (seven, week) (Old Swahili ‘fungate’)
mnani nane (eight)
mpya tisa, kenda (nine)
kummi kumi (ten)
akachukola akachukua (he/she took it away)
akaje akaja (he/she came)
akanepa akanipa (he/she gave me)
akabija akauza (he/she sold it)
akafenga akaiba (he/she stole it)

Place names, languages and ethnonyms mentioned by the Sidis of Sindh and recorded by Burton (1851) are:
Lamo (Lamu along north Kenya coast)
Baramaji (Mbwamaji south of Daressalaam)
Kinkhwere (Kinghwele spoken south of Daressalaam)

Whiteley (1969:52) repoted “ ….. many slaves seem to have come from the coastal areas, and the ‘Sidi’ language appears to have been one they could all speak. ….. Though they include members of some inland tribes, such as Nyamwezi and Sagara, many are easily recognizable as coastal groups, e,g ‘Dengereko, Makonde, Matumbi, Gindo, Mudoe, Mzigra, etc.’ Mr. R. B. Patel, of Nairobi, tells me that there is still a Swahili-speaking ‘Sidi’ community in Kathiawar, in the remote Gir forest some 200 miles S.W. of Ahmedabad.” (This Sidi community is in Jambur, the “Negro Village” with about 150 households, which the present author visited in March 2008.) 

Recent fieldwork among the Sidis in Ratanpur and Bhavnagar in Gujarat during January 2007 has yielded only about a dozen Bantu/Swahili single word items and about a dozen phrases and a couple of complete Swahili-sounding sentences, e.g. “Ee manamuki, wapi koenda?” (You young woman, where are you going?) In modern Swahili it would be ‘Wee mwanamke, unakwenda wapi?’ A couple of sentences were of mixed Bantu-Gujarati construction, e.g. “Kulya karwa jae!” (Let us go to eat! Bantu ‘kulya’ = to eat, eating; Gujarati ‘karwa jae’ = let us go to do). One lexical item, “injoro” (curry, gravy) used in Ratanpur, is not derived from any Bantu language but rather from the Ethiopian usage ‘injira’ (or Somali ‘anjera’). 

4. Summary
In the face of globalization which seems to make the world become more inter-connected, ethnicity is increasingly emphasised in many parts of the world where claims to specific local identities and renewed or (re)constructed ethnicities are more loudly presented.
The Sidis of Gujarat in India are a fragmented East African community of mixed ancestry, primarily descendants of Muslim African traders, sailors and mercenaries. A few of them are of slave origin. Today they speak Gujarati and Cutchi with only a few Swahili/Bantu expressions mostly connected with their Sufi ritual dances and music.

A long period of relative isolation of the Sidis has been broken by both Indian and Western anthropological and historical interest in the various Sidi communities and this has given them a wider recognition both at home and abroad. Since the last few years, Sidi cultural societies have been organising international festivals in Gujarat and participating in international cultural gatherings in East Africa with their song and dance troupes which have also been touring the West. These renewed contacts of the Sidis with East Africa have increased slightly the number of Swahili/Bantu word stock in their Gujarati and Cutchi; for example the Sidis, though being culturally and linguistically de facto Indian, are emphasising their African heritage and their entertainment groups are now increasingly using Swahili greetings when addressing their public, and their men dress like the East African Swahili Muslims. An increasing number of Sidi individuals are also involved in modern sports (football) and athletics (running) especially in Pakistan, thus playing the role of an essential factor of Sidi ethnic identity.

During the last decade, several Western researchers have been emphasizing the ‘africanness’ of the Sidis and have exaggerated their ‘slave origins’ (Kjaerholm 1992, Whitehead 1997 and 1999) which some Sidi groups are capitalising on. Recently a couple of Sidi groups of artists have toured East Africa and Europe on a commercial basis performing Sufi dances and songs with the repertoire in Gujarati and Hindi mixed with some Swahili phrases. It seems, the Sidis are ‘adopting’ Swahili as ‘their’ ancestral language, as many African-American communities have done in the United States. Sufi cult and dance groups (e.g. the ‘Sidi Goma’ and ‘The Black Sufis of Gujarat’), healing rituals, spirit possession and exorcism, and annual celebrations, have become objects of historical and social anthropological research mostly supported by Western institutions and they are increasingly becoming exotic tourist attractions. 

James Clifford rightly points out that “The currency of diaspora discourse extends to a wide range of populations and historical predicaments (1997:257).” Many individuals, groups and whole communities of the African diaspora around the world have reconstructed, reinvented and imagined their ancestral homeland; and the Sidi of Gujarat are increasingly perceiving East Africa, misconceiving particularly Zanzibar, the central slave market of the Indian Ocean during the 18th and 19th centuries, as the home of their African ancestors and Swahili as their ancestral language!

Globalization and technological advances have strongly pushed the Sidi communities in the general trend in the world of nations becoming culturally heterogeneous, with minority languages, or minority language use, in some cases playing the role of an essential factor of ethnic identity, whether traditionally inherited or newly constructed.


References
Alpers Edward A. 2003. The African Diaspora in the Indian Ocean: A Comparative Perspective, in Jayasuriya,
Shihan de Silva and Richard Pankhurst (Eds.), pp. 19-50.
Basu, Helene. 1994. Habshi-Sklaven, Sidi-Fakiren: muslimische Heiligenverehrung im westlichen Indien.
Berlin: Das Arabische bok.
Basu, Helene. 2002. Indian Sidi – African Query. Paper, Indian Ocean Studies Conference, University of
California, Los Angeles.
Bates, D. G. and A. Rassam. 1989. Peoples & Cultures of the Middle East. Trenton NJ: Prentice Hall.
Burton, Richard F. 1851. Sindh, and the Races that inhabit the Valley of the Indus, London.
Camara, Charles. 1997. Afro-Indians – a preliminary survey. Conference Paper, The Northwestern Indian Ocean
as Cultural Corridor, 17-19 January 1997, Dept. of Social Anthropology, Stockholm University, Sweden.
Catlin, Amy. 2002. To tour or To be toured – African Indians at Home and Abroad. Paper, Indian Ocean Studies
Conference, University of California, Los Angeles.
Catlin-Jairazbhoy, Amy and Edward A. Alpers (Eds.). 2004. Sidis and Scholars: Essays on African Indians. 
Trenton, NJ: The Red Sea Press, Inc.
Census of India Vol.5, Part 5B, No.1, 1961. Siddi - a negroid tribe of India. Ethnographic Series, Gujarat.
Census of India Vol.5, Part 6, No.10, 1961. Village Survey Monograph: Jambur. Ethnographic Series, Gujarat.
Census of India. 1981. District census handbook. Village and town directory – Siddi District.
Series 11 Madhya Pradesh, Part XIII-A. 
Clifford, James. 1997. Routes: Travels and Ttranslations in the Late Twentieth Century. Cambridge, Mass.:
Harvard University Press.
Cohen, Robin. 1997. Global Diasporas: An Introduction. London: UCL Press.
CONEXOES. 1989-91. Newsletter of the African Diaspora Research Project, Vols. 1-3. Dept. of Sociology, Michigan State University, East Lancing.
Freeman-Grenville, G.S.P. 1988. The Swahili Coast - 2nd to 19th Centuries. London: Variorum Reprints. (Ch.
XVII The Siddi and Swahili)
Harris, Joseph E. 1977. African presence in Asia: consequences of the East African slave trade. Evanston:
University of Illinois Press.
_____________. 1993. (Ed.) Global dimentions of the African diaspora. Washington: Howard University Press.
_____________. 1998. Africans And Their History. New York: Penguin/Meridian.
Jayasuriya, Shihan de Silva and Richard Pankhurst (Eds.). 2003. The African Diaspora in the Indian Ocean.
Trenton, N.J.: Africa World Press.
Kjaerholm, Lars. 1992. Så överlevde Indiens negerslavar. Illustrerad Vetenskap 3:46-49, 79. Stockholm.
Lemelle, Sidney and Robin D. G. Kelly (Eds.). 1994. Imagining Home – Class, Culture and Nationalism in the
African Diaspora. London and New York: Verso.
Lodhi, Abdulaziz Y. 1992. African Settlements in India. Nordic Journal of African Studies 1(1):83-87.
_____________. African Settlements in India. NAMASKAR-AFRIKANA-L@HOME.EASE.LSOFT.COM,
24 September 1998.
_____________. Sidhi, the East African community in Gujarat: Globalization in earlier days and their situation
today. Paper presented to the Panel on Globalization and Minority Languages in South Asia,
18th European Conference on Modern South Asian Studies, 6-9 July 2004, Lund, Sweden..
Misra, Satish C. 1964. Muslim Communities in Gujarat: Preliminary studies in their History and Social
Organisation. New York: Asia Publishing House.
Naik, T. B. and G. P. Pandya. 1981. The Sidis of Gujarat (A Socio-Economic Study and a Development Plan).
Tribal Research & Training Institute: Ahmedabad.
_____________. 1993. The Sidis of Gujarat (A Socio-Economic Study and a Development Plan).
Tribal Research & Training Institute: Ahmedabad.
OUP 1919, A New English Dictionary on Historical Principles, Vol IX Part I, Oxford University Press, London. 
Patel, Jayanti K. 1986. African Settlements in Gujarat. India Quarterly, July-Sept.:238-246.
Pankhurst, Richard. 2003. The Ethiopian Diaspora to India, in Jayasuriya, Shihan de Silva and Richard
Pankhurst (Eds.), pp. 189-221.
Robbins, Kenneth X. and John McLeod (Editors). 2006. African Elites in India: Habshi Amarat. Ahmedabad. 
Mapin Publishing Pvt, Ltd.
Shepperson, George. 1968. The African Abroad or the African Diaspora, in T. O. Ranger (Ed.), Emerging
Themes of African History. Nairobi: pp. 152-176. 
Shirodkar, P. P. 1985. Slavery in Coastal India. Purabhilekh Puratatva 3(1):27-44. State Archives: Panaji, India.
Shroff, Beheroze. 2002. Sidis and Parsis – a film project. Paper, Indian Ocean Studies Conference, University of
California, Los Angeles.
Whitehead, Andrew. 1997. Stranded In A Foreign Land – an African community without a past. BBC FOCUS
ON AFRICA , Jan-March:28-30. 
_____________. 1999. Asian Blacks’ Unique Past Is Ever Present – the other African Diaspora.
International Herald Tribune, April 13. 
_____________. 2000. The lost Africans of India. The World Today, BBC News Online, Friday 24 November.
Whiteley, Wilfred W. 1969. SWAHILI – The Rise of a National Language. London: Methuen.

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 
This paper is based on the following three short presentations:

1. Sidhi, the East African community in Gujarat: Globalization in earlier days and their situation today. Presented at the 18th European Conference on Modern South Asian Studies, 6-9 July 2004, Lund, Sweden. Panel on Globalization and Minority Languages in South Asia.

2. Linguistic evidence of Bantu origins of the Sidi of Gujarat and the Shidi of Baluchistan. Presented at the International Conference on the Sidis of India and the African Diasporas in the Indian Ocean and Asia, University of Goa, Panajim, India, 9-14 January 2006.

3. The Zanzibari (Jangbari) of India – Identity and Self-awareness among the Sidi of Gujarat. 10th ZIFF Conference on Histories and Memories, 2-4 July 2007, Zanzibar, Tanzania.

Dharma - Mine, Yours, Ours & Theirs

Hinduism is a Dharmic religion. Dharma is the Sanskrit word for duty. Hinduism is known as a Dharmic religion mainly because it emphasizes on ones own duty. There are different types of Dharmas. We all have different duties in this world. Our duties are not always the same.

The Dharmas of Hinduism can be broken down into many types. Here are some of the Dharmas. I have included my own opinion about it. .

Sanatana Dharma (Eternal Law)
This is the laws of the universe as mentioned in our faith. This is the ultimate reality of existence and non-existence. The fact that energy exist, dissolution of cosmos, wind moves, gravity pulls, animal eats, humans worship, fire burns, Vedas as non-human origin etc. Every fact of the universe and beyond is part of Sanatana Dharma.

Samanya Dharma (general duty)
The general duty of all humans is known as Samanya Dharma. We eat, sleep, bathe, interact, move around, perform chores, love, respect, care. It is a general duty which we all do irregardless of who we are. Common for all.

Visesha Dharma (specific duty)
These are the specific duties we encounter in our life. It is the duty of the house owner not his neighbour to paint his own house. It is the duty of a man who drank juice to throw the cup into the dustbin. Others can't be throwing it for him. So we do what is specific to us at that point of time. If I am organizing a feast in my house, then it is my duty to prepare dinner for my guests.

Varnashrama Dharma (duties of social classes)
In Hinduism, societies are divided into classes known as Brahmana (intellectuals and priests), Kshatriya (rulers and enforcers), Vaisya (business class), Sudra (working class). We see these classification in today's society too. It is just that they may not have these Sanskrit name tags on them. Each class has its own duty.

It is the duty of the police officers to protect the citizens. It is the duty of the intellectual community to disseminate proper facts. It is the duty of the politicians to manage the country. It is the duty of the businessmen to fund the nation. It is the duty of the working class to support the nation through their work.

Yuga Dharma (duty of the era)
According to Hinduism, the human civilisation can be divided to several periods. It is mainly known as Satya, Treta, Dvapara and Kali Yuga. Hindu scriptures have its own definition of the things to do and avoided during each of these 4 yugas.

A yuga can also be interpreted as an era. The present era which we humans live in emphasizes on globalisation, democracy and many other values. The concept of Yuga Dharma is applied more on the broader scope of mankind itself rather than on individual humans.

Kula Dharma (duty of clan)
A Kula Dharma is our duty towards our family and extended family. The extended family is known as clan, kulam or jati. We have duties to do towards our own blood relatives. When someone is in trouble, it is our duty as family members to protect them. Whenever there is an event like wedding or even funeral, members of the clan have a duty to do. Their duties are determined through their relationship with each other. For example, when my niece gets married, it is my duty as her maternal uncle to perform certain pre-marital ritual. Kula Dharma also requires members of the clan to help the clan to prosper. Each jati needs to take care of itself and ensure that they have a quality life.

Manava Dharma (duty of mankind)
Manava Dharma is the common duty of humans. It is our duty as humans to ensure that our species continues. It is our duty as humans to manage this planet and protect it from destruction. We have to establish colonies and manage our civilizations. We need to be careful with how we use our resources. It is our duty to be humane in our doings and strive to preserve humanity among us.

Purusha Dharma (duty of husband) & Stri Dharma (duty of wife)
A husband has his duty towards the family. He is responsible as the bread winner for the family. As a father, he needs to protect not just his wife but also his children. The security of the family depends on him. He needs to provide the family with its basic needs. A house to live in, a vehicle to move around, power of purchase 

The duty of the wife, or Stri Dharma is a very special one. Today, most woman have their own career. This also means that we men must share some responsibilities with them.

However, this should not prevent them from carrying out their own duties. Not only that they should love their husbands, it is their duty to nurture the children. No love can replace a mother's love. They have very special place in the family.

It is said that if men are the fence of a family, the women are its pillars.

Raja Dharma (duty of king)
The ruler of a nation is highly responsible for the wellbeing of its people. While it is the duty of the government to manage the country, the ruler is responsible to ensure that the management itself functions well. Today, we live in a democratic society. Therefore, rulers need to also ensure that they do not break the trust of the people who voted them into power.

Praja Dharma (duty of subjects)
As citizens, we are obliged to contribute towards the nation we live in. We pay taxes, obey the law, respect each other and have the power to even select our rulers in today's era. We are also responsible to protect the image of our nation.

Pravritti Dharma (duty in worldly life)
The wordly life has many demands. We need to get married, have children and continue our lineage. Each stage of life has its own needs. Material need is one of it. A house is needed. A mode of transport is needed. Entertainment is also part of the wordly life. We cannot ignore everything and detach ourselves from these. 

Nivritti Dharma (duty in spiritual life)
The demands of spiritual life is different from that of wordly life. Firstly, there are two main stages. One is practicing spiritualism by being part of the wordly life, and the other is through Sanyasa. Sanyasa is practicing spiritualism by detaching ourselves from wordly matters. 

Apad Dharma (duty during distress)
Each duty is different. But duties can be ignored or altered during emergency. For example, a Brahmin priest may see it as his duty to be a vegetarian. But if he is stranded in a land during war and the only way to survive is by eating dog meat, he has to do it in the name of Apad Dharma for the sake of survival. 

It is basic humanity to spread love among mankind. But if violence is needed to protect our families from robbers, then we have no choice but to do it. These are the demands of emergency situation.

So those were some of the basic Dharmas.

When Arjuna rode into the battlefield, he became very depressed. Hundreds of thousands of warriors stood infront of him in the battlefield. They were not only his enemies but also his kins and friends. His own family patriach, Bhisma stood against him.

Arjuna laid down his weapons and decided not to be part of the war.

How can he kill the people who he loved so much?

Krishna then explained that Arjuna has entered the battlefield as a warrior. He has to do his duty as a warrior and participate in the war. 

Even if he is required to kill his loved ones to uphold justice and bring victory to the Pandavas, he has to do it. Because that is his duty at that point of time.

Such conflict of duties happens to us too. This is known as Dharma Sankata. We need to realise that Dharma needs to be applied according to the situation. We need to also find a balance between the various Dharma we do.

Many of the problems in the society today happens because people do not do their Dharma properly. 

It is not the duty of the politicians to become billionaires through fraudulent means. Their duty is to manage the country. Not steal its resources to enrich themselves. If they want to be rich, they should have quit politics and become businessmen.

Similarly, it is the duty of the police force to protect the citizens. It is not their duty to be involved in politics.

What happened in Tibet is a conflict of Dharma too.

The Buddhist leaders known as Dalai Lama are supposed to be focused in spiritualism. It is not their duty to administer a state. They can be an advisor to the ruler, but they should not become the ruler itself.

So this caused Tibet to have weak leadership. It fell into the hands of China. If Tibet had a ruler like the Chinese, China would have not dared to invade it.

So what is the best Dharma among all Dharmas?

As explained by Krishna himself, ones own Dharma is the best Dharma. This is known as Sva Dharma.

Yes we are all humans living in the same planet but each of us have our own Dharma to do in this life. We need to be mindful of our own Dharma and carry out our tasks with sincerity.

Peace will prevail if everyone understood their Dharma. When we disturb the balance of Dharma and prevent others from carrying out their Dharma, Adharma will prevail.

Shreyam SvaDharma!
Shreyam SvaDharma!
Shreyam SvaDharma!



Paal Kudam or Panneer Kudam?


At first, I did not want to write this. I was afraid that some Hindu devotees including my own family members will be offended. However, I want my opinion to be heard, in a nice way.


We know that thousands of devotees offer Paal Kudam (Milk Pots) during each Thaipusam festival.

Firstly, keep in mind that I have nothing against paal abishegam (ritual milk bath) in Hindu temples. It is not wrong at all.

But when we do it together in a very large number, it actually matters a lot. There is a big difference between pouring just 10 litres and 100,000 litres.

Perhaps the temple management can be the only ones who offer Paal Kudam. Probably 10 litres for ritual sake. 

Devotees should be encouraged to bring Panneer Kudam (Rose Water Pots) instead of Paal Kudam as offerings during each Thaipusam especially in Batu Caves.

The smell of rose water is far better than the smell of stale milk. It is also much more hygienic for the environment.

Imagine walking into Batu Caves with a strong fragrance because of the tonnes of rose water poured.

Think about it :)



Jallikattu, Maatu Ponggal & Beef


Today is the 2nd day of Ponggal, the Tamil harvest festival. It is known as Maatu Ponggal (Cattle Ponggal) and it is dedicated to the cattles.

Many would have thought that the Tamils do not eat beef because of Hindu influence. That is not true. It is actualy the culture of the Tamils to respect these animals. Therefore, most Tamils will not eat beef.

The cattles have a very special place in the Tamil society. It helps farmers to plough the land, pull carts and its milk is an important element in the daily lives of the Tamil people. 

Back in the olden days, many women died of child birth. Furthermore, due to poor health condition, many new mothers do not lactate during the first few days after delivery.

In such cases, cow milk is used as a replacement for mother's milk to feed the newborn. So naturally, most Tamils will not eat them.

However, the taboo is not applied to everyone. Tamil clans who are involved with leather works or the make of percussion instruments actually eat beef. The cows are not holy for them as their skin is a source of income.

We also have our own bull taming sport. It is commonly known as Jallikattu. It usually starts on Maatu Ponggal and can last for several weeks.

Unlike the Spanish bullfight, the Tamil Jallikattu does not require the beast to be killed. The ultimate aim is to either subdue the bull or grab the price money which will be tied to its neck. There are several type of Jallikattu sport.

1. The bull will be tied to a pole with a very long rope. Participant (one at a time) have to wrestle and grab the price money.

2. Bulls will be released in a fenced arena or an open arena. Participants will try to wrestle with it in a group and subdue the bull or grab the price money.

Jallikattu is a violent sport. Many participants have been killed by the bulls with its own horns. Some also receive injuries because of being trampled.

Yet, the Tamils do not aim to kill the bull. In fact, the bulls will be venerated. But of course, there will be some rotten apples who abuse the bulls.

Jallikattu was originally practiced by the martial classes. Nowadays, it sees participation from various clans. Jallikattu event was also used as a good avenue to select potential bridegrooms.

Before each event, bulls are brought to the local Muniandy temples for blessings. Such bulls are also nicknamed as Muniandy Kaalai or Kovil Kaalai. Kaalai is the Tamil word for bulls.

The bulls are usually of the Kangeyam breed or the Pulikulam breed. The Pulikulam breed got its name from a village called Pulikulam in my ancestral district, Sivagangai. 

Long ago, there used to be a kulam (pond) in the Pulikulam forest. The local puli (tigers) come there to drink. These tigers were ferocious but the bulls were never afraid of them. Some will fight the tigers till death. So the courageous breed got its name from this place.




Jallikattu bulls are bred specially for the bull fight. They undergo vigorous training under their owners. Bulls will be brought to local water tanks for swimming. Bulls are also trained to ram their horns on thick piles of sands. These are all done to build the stamina and strength of the bulls.

Today's Jallikattu is different from its original form as practiced more than 2000 years ago. There are strict regulations enforced to ensure that both the participants and bulls are protected.


Did Karna Really Pay His Debt?

I wrote this in my Facebook page on 31 December 2013. It is regarding Karna and the Red Rice Debt...

(read further after the words in Yellow Italic)



RED RICE DEBT

Most of you would know the song "Ullathil Nalla Ullam" from the movie Karnan. Nobody can ever replace the late Sivaji for that role.


This is part of the lyric:


Senchottru Kadan Theerkka

Saeraatha Idam Sernthu
Vanjathil Veezhnthaayada Karnaa
Vanjagan Kannanadaa
Karnaa, Vanjagan Kannanadaa

Do you know what is meant by "Senchottru Kadan Theerkka"?


Well this is referring to Red Rice Debt. 


Back during ancient times, cooked rice will be spread in front of the king.


The king will then roll it into small rice balls and give it to the warriors with his own hand. Warriors who eat the rice ball from the hand of the king will swear that they will protect the king with their own life. 


If the king dies or get slain in the battle, they will all commit suicide. It was one of the many ritual suicide or harakiri of ancient Tamil warriors.


Why is it known as Senchoru (Red Rice)? Probably because it will be mixed with the blood of a sacrificed animal.


The Thirumurugatruppadai, an ancient Tamil poem also mentioned that rice balls mixed with the blood of ram is given as offering to Murugan.


So in this song, Senchottru is used as a metaphor for loyalty. That is the beauty of Kannadasan's lyrics.


Karna was very loyal towards his friend Duryodhana. Despite knowing that the Pandavas were his brothers, despite knowing that Duryodhana was wrong, he stood by his side.


In the end, he died as a tragic hero due to his loyalty but he paid the red rice debt


In this post, I mentioned that Karna paid his debt but a telephone call which I received later made me to rethink about it.

So who called me? Who else if it is not the grand master himself, Dr.S.Jayabarathi.

As usual, our conversation did its 'travels'. We spoke about many things. There were reference to Cholas, their Solar lineage and many other things which I will write on another day.

Back to Karna.....

Dr pointed out a few other things which could possibly mean that Karna did not pay his debt.

For a start, he did not kill Arjuna in the battle. Arjuna was his brother but also the enemy of the Kauravas. Since Karna fought on the Kaurava's side, he has the moral duty to vanquish the enemy.

You see what happened was he made several promises to his mother, Kunti. He promised not to harm any of the Pandavas except Arjuna. He also promised not to release the arrow more than once at him and that too only by aiming the head and not the chest.

So when Karna took to battle and released the arrow, he aimed it towards Arjuna's head. Krishna, the master of Maya, then easily protected Arjuna. 

Karna will then refuse to release another arrow which could have killed Arjuna and ensured Kaurava a victory. The charioteer will also ask Karna to release the arrow but all those will fall on his deaf ears. 

Why? Because he could not break the promises made.

In the end, Karna will be slain. The Kauravas will loose the battle. A battle which could have been won only if Karna did not make any promise to Kunti.

Was it wrong to make such promises to his mother Kunti? It was actually an injustice to Duryodhana.

You see, Karna was wrapped in a cloth, put inside a trunk and dumped into the river by Kunti when he was a newborn. Karna was raised by charioteers.

So during an archery competition, Karna will be denied the right to participate. Because he does not know his parents and being a person who is unsure of his own ancestry, he was disqualified to compete with the princes who were Kshatriyas.

Varna could be changed. It is not hereditary.

At that point of time, Duryodhana steps in. Takes Karna as his own, gives a potion of his land and qualifies him into the Kshatriya varna. 

He saved Karna's honor and that made Karna indebted to him.

So was it right for Karna to make such promises to Kunti when it is a treachery against Duryodhana? Perhaps the Mahabaratha enthusiast who is reading this can discuss.

Did Karna really pay his debt? 



Tamil Surnames and Hypocrisy

Many Tamils will go berserk when we speak about surnames. This is because the surnames reflects the caste or clan. Most of the surnames we have are occupational surnames.

Each occupational surnames of the Tamil people has its own history and it is clan specific. This is mainly because those clans had their own hereditary occupation in the past. 

Take for example the surname Servai used in the Mukkulathor community. It refers to a person who's ancestors were Servaikarars (men who serve). These Servaikarars defended forts and worked inside the palaces. Some also served as royal bodyguards.

The Latin word for service is Servus. It is also used as a surname by Europeans who had the same function in the society as our own Servaikarars. Perhaps the Latin word Servus is a corruption of the Tamil word Servai or vice versa.

Are we Tamils the only ones who have occupational surnames?

Let's take a look at our very own modern Asian role models, the Japanese society and their surnames.

The Kaji were metal workers, the Inukai were dog breeders, the Akazome were dyers and the Hattori were weavers. The Wataribe or Watanabe were ferry service providers.


Japanese actor, Ken Watanabe
What about the European surnames?

The Bergers were shepherds, the Kellogg were animal slaughterers, Smith were metal workers, Schneider were tailors, Walkers shrunk woolen cloth, the Proctor collected tax and the Tyler made tiles.


Originally known as Walker's Kilmarnock Whisky, the Johnnie Walker brand is a legacy left by John "Johnnie" Walker after he started to sell whisky in his grocer's shop in Ayrshire, Scotland.

Not only does these European or Japanese surnames have occupational origins, the clans which used it also practiced endogamy in the past. Endogamy means they do not marry outside their clan and they keep their profession within the family. 

Isn't this similar to us Tamils and the rest of India? Our surnames too have occupational origins and our clans too practiced endogamy. Our ancestors too kept their profession within the family just like what the Europeans did in the past


India's billionaire, Shiv Nadar.
How different are these surnames from Tamil surnames like Asari (metal workers), Stapathi (stone masons and temple builders), Pattar (goldsmiths), Chettiar (merchants), Udayar (landlord), Padayachi (army man), Konar (shepherds), Kudumbar (Pallar village headman), Mudaliar (first ranked)?

I see no difference at all. Only the language used is different.

The Japanese and the European people do not live in denial of their heritage. But we are doing the exact opposite and we are still stuck in it.

We condemn our own race whenever we see Tamil people with these surnames. We also put the blame on Hinduism by claiming that it is a religion that promotes discrimination. 

Castes and occupational surnames are not a Hindu invention. Every society has its own clan divisions and its own list of surnames. Yet, we failed to realise that it is the same everywhere. 

We need to learn about other cultures and see the similarities with our own culture. Let's not live like a frog under the coconut shell.


(Picture taken from another blog)

CMM & Character Assassination

I was dragged into controversy twice this year. The first one happened in August when someone created a fake ID under my profile name. They then spread false news that I was the admin of the infamous Facebook page The Comedy Machas & Machis a.k.a CMM.







This issue was then settled when I reported it to FB support. They removed the fake profile. But I don't know what they did with this fake Sharmalan Thevar. God knows who commented what with it.

I am not sure why I was framed as the admin of CMM. My blog was also highlighted. It was a time when the original CMM page was about to be closed down. Perhaps someone felt that it was better to put me in trouble and divert the attention of the public.

A relative of mine even called up to inform that people were looking for me as they want to take revenge on CMM admins. They then found out that it was a hoax and I am not involved with CMM.

So I escaped without harm. Vasuge was pregnant at that time. Imagine the fear she would have had in her.

As that issue was settled quickly, I continued with my blogging. As you all know, my blog contains many articles which focuses on Indian history particularly those concerning the various castes or clans we have.

Since it involves the various castes, I have always been careful with my choice of words. This is because caste is a very sensitive issue. Therefore, one has to be very cautious when writing about it. Furthermore, I have to write about castes because it is impossible to separate it from Indian history.

How does one explain the invasion of Thondaimandalam by Athondai Chola without mentioning about the massacre of Kurumba tribes and the resettlement of Vellalars which later created a new identity known as Thondaimandalam Vellalar a.k.a Mudaliars???

Most of you won't even understand what is mentioned above :)

On 27 December this year, while preparing for my daughter's fullmoon celebration, I was alerted by a friend that I was once again dragged into controversy. This time by the admin of CMM itself.

So what did they highlight this time? Well, they targeted my clan group, the Malaysian Mukkulathors and branded me as a caste fanatic.


Firstly, CMM admins or their supporters know nothing about my clan group. Because it is a closed group. I know that someday someone is going to create a baseless issue out of it. This is why the group never functioned as an open public group.

Many do not know that the 500 members of this group are actually related to each other. We come from various families comprising 38 family names. The 38 family names and 500 members are divided among three clans known as the Kallar, Maravar and Agamudayar people. Hence, the terminology Mukkulathor (people of the three clans) is used.

Most of us trace our origins to the districts of Ramanathapuram, Sivagangai, Pudukottai, Tiruvarur and Thanjavur. Alot of us share common ancestors from the same village. This group has been active since 16 October 2009. 

So why should CMM or its supporters feel disturbed when 500 relatives decide to be in a Facebook group? 

The Chinese, Irish, Malays all have their own clan associations. You cannot simply join Persatuan Anak-Anak Bugis Selangor if you are not a Bugis. Similarly, you cannot walk into the Liew Clan Association if you are not one of them.

The same concept is applied for the Malaysian Mukkulathors group and all the other Indian clan association. It is formed purely with the intention of bringing our relatives closer and tracing our roots. 

There are dozens of Indian clan associations in Facebook. The Udayars, Vanniars, Nadars, Vellala Gounder, Pallars all have it. People of the same jathi (clan) are actually relatives. They share common ancestry and there is nothing wrong if they decide to bond with their kinsmen.

Of course, many will not understand this as they don't even know the basics of history.

I am sure many of you heard about Dato Haji Thasleem. He is a nice man who has done alot for the poor. But how many of you are aware that he is also the president of an association known as Malaysia Alagankulam Muslim Jamath?




I am merely showing an example of another organisation which has similar concept although it is non-Hindu and Muslim. Clan and ancestral village matters to some because it is all about their extended family.

One of my blog reader is from the Nagarathar clan. His family has a family office in Pillaiyarpatti. They have a record of their family tree up to 1000 years. One branch of the clan is currently 20,000 big.

Will CMM attack the other Indian clan associations just like how they attacked mine? 

So why did CMM selectively targeted me and my blog only? You ponder upon that by yourself.

The FB group Malaysian Mukkulathors never at any point of time involved itself in activities which could disrupt the harmony in Indian community. On other words, we never "cari pasal" with anyone. 

(Click to read what CMM said about me. View the comments)

It was CMM which started the fight. They claim that it is against humanity and that I was bribed extra 5kg of rice by BN and old clothes by Dato G for being a Thevar. 

Why such cheap statement??

Their followers then went on to pass personal remarks on me. All without reading my blog post properly.

(Click to read what CMM said about my wife. View the comments)

When one of them tagged my wife in their post, my wife responded by stating that people are just throwing their words without investigating.

Someone then took a screenshot of that and mocked my wife in CMM when most of them don't even know her personally. The verbal attacked continued. 

Is this how we foster harmony among Indians in Malaysia?

However, there were a few of them who cared to first check before commenting. Here is an example of a guy who disagreed with CMM on their wall post.


Most of them who commented in CMM and the admin of CMM itself do not understand the complexity of Indian demographics. Many are not even aware of the vast difference we have within our community. Speaking about it is not wrong at all. 

If Indians do not research on their own clan roots, who else will? We cannot expect Edgar Thurston to return from his grave and do another research for us.

How many of you even know that matrilineal system like the one practiced by the Minangkabaus still exist among 18 Tamil clans?

Of course most of you don't know and don't care about it. So why bother commenting about someone who does research on such topics especially when no caste was insulted?

As what one of my blog follower said:

"Indians in pathetic condition because all their judgments are made in emotional basis rather thn rational..without knowing head and tail simply go beserk and unleash hatred..very sad with this kind of chracter assasination."

This guy is actualy right. 

Just because I run a FB group for my relatives in the clan and write in blog about various clans, CMM decided to use this to their advantage and spoil my name. 

As usual, those who commented in CMM never bothered to think about this. They behaved like a herd of sheep which blindly follows the shepherd.

Interestingly, these people also failed to realize that just a few days ago, on 18 December, I wrote an article on inter caste marriage and how it can be practiced in the Indian diaspora. I doubt any caste fanatic will even think of writing an article that promotes inter caste marriage.


To all those CMM fans and admins, if you are unhappy with my blog or my affiliation with my clan, then it is just too bad that I can't do anything to please you. 

I don't see anything wrong to be affiliated with my clan, use my hereditary surname or blog about Indian history. This is my rights and it is actually none of your business.

You have over 17,000 fans. 
A dozen admins.
Yet you are afraid of a group of 500 clan members managed by 1 admin?
You must be a special kind of coward hiding behind Senthil's face.


CMM's decent reply to someone who tried explaining about my blog. This is how they promote unity among Indians.

Are All Religions Really the Same?

Are all religions the same? Do they all teach the same things? We would have grown up hearing from our elders that all religions teach the s...